Rare Carat Review 2025

Whether you’re looking to purchase an engagement ring, a wedding ring, earrings, necklaces, or whatever else that includes beautiful diamonds, you need to find the right company. You can’t just rock up to any place and expect to find the best quality that you can afford straight off the bat.

In order to get this right, you need to do your research into the various options that are available on the market right now. Part of the fun of purchasing diamonds is the search for the one that stands out to you and the jeweler that can help you find something beautiful. Sure, it makes the process take longer, but time will pass anyway!

So, when you’re doing your diamond shopping, you should be thinking about where you can purchase from to get the best, and Rare Carat is certainly that. With a near-perfect 5.0/5 score on Trustpilot over 3,000 reviews, they beat all the legacy competitors (James Allen is rated 4.2, Blue Nile 4.1, Brilliant Earth 4.3, Ritani 2.5). They were even vetted and featured in a case study by Trustpilot. Verified customer reviews matters, and as their CEO puts it: “With the internet being saturated with fake recommendations from paid affiliates, we wanted to bet on real customer feedback”. 

Who Is Rare Carat?

Rare Carat is an online jeweler purchase the finest engagement rings or other jewelry. They are a US based company that brings together some of the best expertise from across the industry, ensuring that shoppers receive the best possible product to suit their needs.

Since being initially formed back in 2016, Rare Carat has taken the diamond industry by storm, and become one of the most trusted brands for engagement rings and other diamond jewelry in less than ten years, proving their quality. 

What Do They Have On Offer?

If you search through their website, you will find a fair few different products, all of which are forms of jewelry. What you will find more than anything else though are engagement rings as that is the area in which they specialize. With a wide range of engagement rings on offer, it’s unlikely that you won’t be able to find what you are looking for on this site. 

One of the most important parts of their service is the fact that they offer transparency and protection to all of their customers. It seems important to Rare Carat that every person who purchases on their website understands where their products are coming from, and fully understands what they are purchasing. 

What Are The Pros Of Their Diamond Jewelry?

First, when combing through their site, you will find various different sections dedicated to elements of purchasing an engagement ring so that you can filter your search easily. You will find headings such as style and metal, but there is also an entire section to build a custom ring if you would prefer to do this.

Their team includes over 100 GIA-trained gemologists to help you buy intelligently. Also on the team are data scientists and math PHD graduates who work on analyzing the pricing and trends to ensure that the products they offer are as reasonably priced as they can be.

One of the biggest pros of Rare Carat has got to be the large selection of products that they offer. While the specialization is in engagement rings, they don’t just limit their range to them, offering high-quality jewelry options across the board. 

The final pro we’re going to mention is that the whole buying process is pressure free. You are free to change your mind at any given time, and there are a whole team of people around to help you with whatever you need at any time.

What Are The Cons?

Like everything else in the world, there have to be some cons. You can’t have the ups without the downs!

The biggest downside of Rare Carat is that they only ship to the US and Canada, but Europe is excluded.

Some customers have also complained that they don’t accept bitcoin as a payment method – but that is also the case for Rare Carat’s competitors.

Is There Anything Else To Note?

If you’re unsure about what you want to purchase, there is a handy quiz on the homepage of Rare Carat that you can use to ascertain what kind of diamond you are looking for. 

As well as that, the company offers free insured shipping on all products and returns that may be needed. On top of that, there is a 30-day money back guarantee if you are not happy with what you receive, so you have time to ensure that you’re getting what you want, and then decide whether you want to keep it, all without losing out.

The Final Verdict

So, are Rare Carat really worth using? The honest answer is yes. They are a fantastic company that offer nothing short of excellence to all of their customers. The products are incredible, the service is top notch, and there is simply just so much to love about this business. To us, the small issues that some customers experience are incomparable to the brilliance of the rest of the business, making it well worth the time.