Notable Westchester NY Medical Malpractice Verdicts and Awards: The Lawyers Behind the Cases
Westchester County juries and courts have produced some of New York’s largest medical malpractice recoveries. They range from multimillion-dollar birth injury settlements to record verdicts against hospitals and physicians.
Local residents should know that behind some of those numbers sits a small group of White Plains and northern Westchester firms that handle these cases year after year. This article profiles the firms most associated with medical malpractice recoveries in Westchester county and what sets each apart.
The figures below come from each firm’s own reported results and from public coverage where available. A reported gross verdict is not the same as a final recovery, because New York verdicts are often reduced or settled before appeal, so read each figure as the firm’s account of the result.
Why New York Medical Malpractice Awards Run So High
New York places no cap on noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases. Pain and suffering can be awarded at any amount, which is the single biggest reason verdicts here climb into the eight figures.
This drives the pattern that follows. New York reports the highest total medical malpractice payouts of any state, and the largest Westchester recoveries cluster in two case types: catastrophic birth injury and delayed diagnosis.
The Westchester Law Firms Behind the County’s Medical Malpractice Recoveries
The firms most identified with Westchester medical malpractice work cluster in White Plains, with one notable practice based north in Ossining. They range from boutique trial practices to century-old litigation firms.
Meagher & Meagher, P.C. (Meagher & Clarke)
Meagher & Meagher is best known for birth injury and obstetric malpractice, including what the firm describes as two of the highest medical malpractice verdicts in Westchester County history, both reached in 2009.
Reported results include:
- $35 million arbitration award for multiple plaintiffs injured by an orthopedist (2019)
- $7.8 million verdict for a delayed tumor diagnosis in a two-year-old causing hearing loss and facial paralysis (2018)
- $3 million to $3.5 million settlements for anaphylaxis, newborn cardiac injury, and birth-related developmental delays
The practice is led by Christopher B. Meagher, a Fordham Law graduate admitted in 1993 who trained as an architect before joining his father’s firm. Meagher & Meagher, P.C. operates from Church Street in White Plains and is transitioning to the name Meagher & Clarke.
What sets it apart: depth in catastrophic birth injury, the case type that produces the county’s largest awards. The firm also states it holds New York’s largest dental malpractice verdict.
Jeffrey Weiskopf, P.C.
Jeffrey Weiskopf, P.C. is a boutique medical malpractice firm distinguished by direct, partner-only handling and its base in northern Westchester rather than the White Plains cluster.
Reported results include:
- $3,250,000 for a failed urologic surgery
- $1,800,000 for a failure to diagnose lung cancer
- $950,000 for a failure to diagnose glaucoma
- $775,000 for a failed knee surgery
The firm states it has recovered more than $20 million in verdicts and settlements, with results weighted toward failure-to-diagnose and surgical-error claims, including several cancer and delayed-diagnosis injuries.
Jeffrey Weiskopf is the named principal on every file the firm litigates, so clients work with the lawyer whose name is on the door rather than being passed to an associate. He holds a J.D. from Cardozo School of Law, served as an adjunct professor there, and previously worked as a senior court attorney in the Manhattan courts.
What sets it apart: a single-principal structure and an Ossining base, making it the natural access point for claimants in northern Westchester communities far from the White Plains courthouse corridor. Readers can review the firm directly through Jeffrey Weiskopf, P.C.
Fiedler Deutsch, LLP
Fiedler Deutsch is a White Plains firm built around two partners who handle cases directly rather than delegating them.
Reported results include:
- $6.35 million for a family whose relative died after an abnormal x-ray was never reported
- $5.5 million wrongful death recovery involving a primary care physician’s failure to monitor cardiac health (Westchester County)
- $4 million federal tort claim for negligent postoperative care at a veterans’ hospital
The firm states it has recovered more than $275 million for clients. Partners Duane Fiedler and Adam Deutsch bring more than fifty years of combined experience, and both have been named “Medical Malpractice Lawyer of the Year” honorees by a national peer-review publication.
What sets it apart: a failure-to-diagnose and failure-to-report focus, particularly wrongful death cases, handled start to finish by a named partner.
Worby Vecchio Edelman, LLP
Worby Vecchio Edelman, formerly Worby Groner Edelman, is among the largest and most established plaintiff’s firms in Westchester, reporting more than $1 billion recovered across its history.
Reported results include a $43 million recovery for malpractice during childbirth, alongside major roadway, construction, and product liability recoveries. The firm is nationally known for representing thousands of September 11 first responders.
Founded in 1978 and based on Main Street in White Plains, it is led by senior partners including David E. Worby and Richard S. Vecchio, a past president of the Westchester County Bar Association.
What sets it apart: scale. A deep bench and the resources to carry catastrophic birth injury cases, which produce its largest figures, through years of litigation.
Law Offices of Thomas L. Gallivan, PLLC
Thomas L. Gallivan’s firm concentrates on birth injury and nursing home cases and reports a roster of Westchester settlements.
Reported results include:
- $9.5 million birth injury settlement involving a failure to perform a timely emergency cesarean
- $2 million failure-to-diagnose-cancer settlement (Westchester County)
- $1.95 million anesthesiology malpractice settlement (Westchester County)
- $1.1 million wrongful death settlement involving an untreated kidney stone
The firm is also connected to the well-documented Michael Colombini case, in which a six-year-old died after an oxygen tank was pulled into an MRI magnet at Westchester Medical Center.
Thomas Gallivan previously defended nursing homes and insurers before moving to the plaintiff’s side. The firm operates from Main Street in White Plains.
What sets it apart: the pairing of birth injury and nursing home neglect, two case types that turn on detailed medical chronologies.
Lever & Ecker, PLLC
Lever & Ecker is a White Plains firm that handles medical malpractice among its personal injury practice areas and distinguishes itself by deliberately limiting its caseload.
The firm caps each lawyer’s active cases at roughly 25 to 30, which it presents as a way to give malpractice and birth injury matters closer attention than a high-volume practice can. It reports more than seventy years of combined experience.
Attorneys David B. Lever and Daniel G. Ecker anchor the practice, with Ecker having chaired the Trial Lawyers Section of the New York State Bar Association.
What sets it apart: the limited-caseload model, for claimants who want a smaller docket and more direct attorney involvement.
Clark, Gagliardi & Miller, P.C.
Clark, Gagliardi & Miller is one of the oldest litigation firms in Westchester, founded in 1907, and handles medical malpractice within a broad trial practice.
Its history includes attorneys who became judges and district attorneys, among them a presiding appellate judge, a Westchester district attorney, a federal judge, and a past president of both the state and county bar associations.
Based on Court Street in White Plains, the firm includes attorney John S. Rand, a trained pharmacist before law school who brings a clinical background to medical cases.
What sets it apart: institutional trial experience, with a century of courtroom work and a roster of alumni who shaped the local bench and bar.
Curan & Ahlers, LLP
Curan & Ahlers is a White Plains firm handling personal injury, medical malpractice, and products liability, distinguished by a stated willingness to try cases rather than settle cheaply.
Established in 1986, the firm reports recovering millions in verdicts and settlements and litigates across Westchester, Rockland, and Sullivan counties. It is led by senior partner Keith J. Ahlers and operates from Mamaroneck Avenue in White Plains.
What sets it apart: a trial-forward posture combined with products liability depth, useful where a defective device or equipment sits alongside provider negligence.
Law Offices of Norman Gershon
The Law Offices of Norman Gershon is a Westchester-focused practice emphasizing hospital negligence, nursing home neglect, and birth injury work.
The firm reports recovering more than $100 million in settlements and verdicts and brings more than thirty-five years of experience serving White Plains, Yonkers, Mount Vernon, and New Rochelle.
What sets it apart: a long-running, locally rooted Westchester practice focused on negligence against hospitals and care facilities.
What the Recoveries Reveal
Case type drives outcome more than firm size. Birth injury and missed-cancer claims with clear liability carry large exposure regardless of which firm handles them, because New York’s uncapped pain-and-suffering damages let a Westchester jury weight the award toward non-economic loss.
Two Rules That Decide Whether a Case Survives
Two New York rules matter most for any Westchester claim:
- The filing deadline. Generally two and a half years from the malpractice, with extensions for continuous treatment and for misdiagnosed cancer under Lavern’s Law. Claims against a public hospital like Westchester Medical Center require a notice of claim within 90 days, which can end a strong case if missed.
- The expert requirement. New York requires the plaintiff’s attorney to certify they consulted a qualified medical expert before filing, a lighter threshold than the pre-suit expert affidavit some states demand.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is different. If you were injured in New York, contact a licensed attorney to discuss your specific situation.
